Afrique Asie Europe Moyen-Orient Internet Nations unies
Haiti31 March 2003

Murdered journalist’s family lose new bid to be civil party in prosecution

The Port-au-Prince appeals court refused on 27 March to consider cancelling a lower court ruling that the family of murdered Haitian journalist Brignol Lindor had failed to properly register as a civil party associated with the prosecution of his killers.

The lawyer for Lindor’s father Belrosier and his brother Moréno said the matter would be appealed to the supreme court. He said Haitian law did not require a formal procedure for being a civil party when a case was brought by a public prosecutor. The status should have been automatically granted when the two men appeared before the judge investigating the case, Fritzner Duclair, and called for justice to be done. If the supreme court also rejected their request, he said, they could seek recognition as civil parties when the trial started.

3 December 2001 - 3 December 2002 - Murder of journalist Brignol Lindor One year of impunity

(JPEG) A year after the killing of Brignol Lindor (see photo), a journalist with the Echo 2000 radio station in Petit-Goâve, Reporters Without Borders, the Damocles Network and the Haitian Journalists’ Association (AJH) deplore the fact that those responsible have not yet been punished.

The three organisations said they were determined to win justice for Lindor, who was beaten to death on 3 December last year by supporters of President Jean-Bertrand Aristide’s Fanmi Lavalas party.

The AJH and Pastor Denis Laguerre (representing the Lindor family), supported by Haiti’s Ecumenical Centre for Human Rights, formally protested on 1 and 3 October before the Port-au-Prince appeals court against the murder enquiry being officially closed, thus excluding any prosecution of the instigator of the attack.

Reporters Without Borders and the Damocles Network may file an appeal before the Inter-American Commission of Human Rights (IACHR).

"A year after Lindor’s death, impunity still reigns," said Reporters Without Border secretary-general Robert Ménard and AJH secretary-general Guyler C. Delva. "It has been turned into a policy aimed at fostering an atmosphere of terror and silencing the media." They said seven journalists were currently in hiding in Gonaives after being threatened by Amiot Métayer, a fugitive from justice protected by Aristide’s party who is terrorising the local population and the press."

(JPEG) Fritzner Duclair, the judge investigating Lindor’s death (see photo), officially closed his enquiry on 16 September. A fact-finding mission by Reporters Without Borders and the Damocles Network published earlier that month noted that the chief instigator of the murder, Petit-Goâve’s assistant mayor Dumay Bony, had not been troubled or charged.

Bony had called at a press conference on 30 November last year for "zero tolerance" to be applied to Lindor, who he called a "terrorist." His words were taken by everyone except Haitian legal officials as an appeal to kill the journalist. Many in Haiti consider the term "zero tolerance," first used by President Aristide a few months earlier to urge police to deal firmly with criminals, as virtual approval of lynching people.

The Haitian authorities told the Organisation of American States (OAS) in a report on 4 November this year that 10 people had been charged in the case, two of whom had been arrested. But Reporters Without Borders find that these two, Maxi Zéphyr and Fritzler Doudoute, are in fact being held for other reasons. Prison officials in Port-au-Prince, where Zéphyr is being held, have also refused for several months to allow him to be questioned in the Lindor murder case.


To mark the first anniversary of Lindor’s death, Reporters Without Borders and the AJH are broadcasting on Haitian radio stations a message from his family demanding justice (see photo). The text is as follows:

" [voice of Robert Ménard] : 3 December 2001 to 3 December 2002

[voice of Moréno Lindor] : My name is Moréno Lindor. I’m the brother of the journalist Brignol Lindor. I was at home the day I heard he had been chopped to death. I feared it was the end for my family. I was wrong. But we were threatened and had to flee the country. A year later, the killers can still count on the inertia of the authorities. The hardest thing is the injustice of it, that nobody has been punished. My brother was killed because he allowed everyone to speak on the radio. Haitians must be given their say and Brignol must be given justice.

[Ménard] In solidarity with the Haitian media, Reporters Without Borders and the AJH add their voices to those of all who demand justice, justice for Brignol Lindor. "


The Haitian Journalists’ Association, Reporters Without Borders and the Damocles Network demand:

-  That the Port-au-Prince appeals court cancels Judge Duclair’s closure of the enquiry and orders the case to be reopened.

-  That the next judge in charge of the case brings charges against Dumay Bony for "incitement to murder."

-  That the Port-au-Prince prison authorities allow Maxi Zéphyr to be questioned about his suspected part in Lindor’s killing.


The two organisations also reiterate their appeal to President Jean-Bertrand Aristide (see photo) to specifically condemn public lynchings and take action to end the impunity enjoyed by the killers and attackers of journalists.

In this country
3 December - Haiti
Seven years after radio journalist’s murder, convicted killers still at large
13 May - Haiti
Finger pointed at US interposition force in the 2004 death of journalist Ricardo Ortega
11 April - Haiti
Responses from Sen. Rudolph Boulos and Harold Sévère to Reporters Without Borders release on Jean Dominique murder
25 January - Haiti
Victory over impunity “within reach” in Lindor murder after seven are convicted in absentia
13 December - Haiti
Two gang members get life for journalist’s murder, a third is acquitted

in the annual report
Haiti - Annual Report 2008
Haiti - Annual report 2007
Haiti - Annual report 2006

In this country
7 November - International
Leaders at Ibero-American summit urged to defend press freedom
15 June - Antigua and Barbuda
Two CARICOM journalists expelled without justification
10 May - International
Leaders attending EU - Latin America summit urged to do more for press freedom
13 October - International
Call for vigilance and responsibility from leaders at Ibero-American summit
18-19 November - Costa Rica

Cuba and Colombia: a nightmare for journalists

in the annual report

14 March 2008 - Cuba
No surrender by independent journalists, five years on from “black spring”
5 June 2007 - Venezuela
Closure of Radio Caracas Televisión consolidates media hegemony
22 May 2007 - Colombia
Paramilitary "black eagles" poised to swoop down on press

Americas press releases
3 June - United States
President Obama urged to raise freedom of expression in his Cairo speech
29 May - Venezuela
Open letter to President Hugo Chavez to protest about official hounding of Globovisión
27 May - Mexico
Crime reporter abducted and killed in Durango state
20 May - Cuba
Anyone can browse the Internet... unless they are Cuban
15 May - Cuba
Journalist gets three-year jail sentence

Americas archives
2009 archives
2008 archives
2007 archives
2006 archives
2005 archives
2004 archives
2003 archives
2002 archives
2001 archives
2000 archives

Sign the petitions
Miguel Galván Gutiérrez
Fabio Prieto Llorente
United States
Chauncey Bailey
A petition to Raúl Castro